Cortland County High School Sports Game Recaps (April 12th)

(Original photo provided by McGraw Varsity Boys Soccer Head Coach Jamey Crumb).

Here are some local high school varsity game recaps from Monday’s games:

McGraw Varsity Boys Soccer vs. Cincinnatus

Team 1st 2nd OT Final
McGraw 0 0 1 1
Cincinnatus 0 0 0 0


The McGraw Golden Eagles were able to get a thrilling 1-0 overtime win over their Sectional and County rivals Cincinnatus. 

With both teams scoreless at the end of regulation, they went into a sudden death overtime (first goal wins). 

With about four minutes into overtime, Nate Stiles scored the winning goal off of a header at the far post. Stiles’ goal was assisted by Jackson Card. 

“The seniors on this team have never won against Cincy and we told them before the game that if we are playing for anything this year, it’s to win this game,” said McGraw Head Coach Jamey Crumb. “This is their sectionals and Cortland State rivalry game and they have to play like it. It was no easy task, as Cincy controlled much of the middle which they typically do. Cason and Scotty work so well together and move off the ball which makes it difficult to mark.”

“Coming off a good win Friday helped with our confidence coming in, but not letting this team score is a task I wasn’t sure we could do,” added Coach Crumb. “They are a great team and it was really a well played game. I am just so proud and happy for these guys, they really deserve it.”

McGraw ended the game with a total of 7 shots and 20 saves from goalkeeper Nolan Knickerbocker; while Cincinnatus had 32 shots and 4 saves from Kooper Vosburg. 

McGraw Varsity Girls Soccer vs. Cincinnatus

Team 1st 2nd Final
McGraw 2 1 3
Cincinnatus 1 0 1


The McGraw Lady Eagles defeated Cincinnatus with a score of 3-1. 

It was a close first half, with both teams being able to get on the scoreboard. Bailey Meade and Gracie McCall scored the first two goals of the game to give McGraw a 2-0 lead. However, Kyla Sustad would keep Cincinnatus in the game with a goal of her own to make it 2-1 at the half. 

McGraw’s Emily Fish scored the final goal of the game off a through ball from Bayley Meade. McGraw ended the game with 24 shots and 4 saves from Jaiden Cortez; while Cincinnatus had 9 shots and 21 saves from Gabriella Taylor. 

Cortland Varsity Girls Volleyball vs. ESM

Team 1st 2nd 3rd 4th Final
Cortland 22 25 25 26 3
ESM 25 18 9 24 1


The Cortland Purple Tigers improved to a 6-2 record after defeating East Syracuse Minoa (ESM) in four sets on Monday. 

After losing a close first set with a score of 22-25, the Tigers went on to win the following three sets (25-18), (25-9), and (26-24). 

Cortland was led by Lexi Zacek (9 kills & 14 digs), Marissa Parzynski (7 kills & 4 digs), Julia Guest (8 kills), Jenn Baker (10 assists & 8 digs), Alyssa Greenwood (23 digs), and Alex Gier (7 point blocks). 

ESM was led by Laura Sitnik (12 kills), Autumn Stoia (11 kills), Helaina Scolaro (18 digs), and Alana Day (25 assists).